Thread:Sannse/@comment-24567264-20130614195638/@comment-8-20130615000159

That depends. "Wikia-hating" sounds as though you are talking about an abusive wiki that attacks Wikia in an offensive and unreasoning way. That's one that we would likely close. However, a wiki that's critical of Wikia in a thoughtful and non-offensive way, would likely be left open

It's basically the difference between "WIKIA STAFF ARE STUPID BARNACLES WHO SHOULD ALL DIE" and "Wikia staff were wrong, the walls should have been painted yellow and not blue - it's sunnier.  Someone should be fired for that"

You titled this "Paradox", and I'm not sure what you mean by that. Possibly you are saying that if we don't close some wikis, we shouldn't close any? But the nature of the wiki does matter. We'd leave that hypothetical critical one open, but we close wikis every day - either because they never got started, or because of explicit content, spam, illegal download links, offensive topics, or other problems.